Order Online



  • Due to the fact that cheese is perishable, we will only ship Monday-Tuesday.
  • We highy recommend that you select the shipping option that allows the cheese to arrive within 2 days.  We are not responsible for the cheese if you select 3 day shipping or longer...as ice packs only stay cold for so long. :) 
  • Due to fluctuations in our inventory, all cheeses may not be available for immediate shipment.  Contact us if you want to confirm what is available.
  • Thanks for your uderstanding!




CLICK HERE if you are PICKING UP GIFT BOXES - select the gift box(es) from the "Cheese Gift Boxes to Pickup" - you will give you the pricing without the cost of the insulated boxes and ice packs.  Make sure you select "Picking Up" when you are prompted to choose deliveyr method.


CLICK HERE if you are SHIPPING CHEESE GIFT BOXES- select the gift box(es) from the "Cheese Gift Boxes for Shipping" - you must enter each order separately.

Phone In Orders:   To place a Phone In Order, please call 317-331-5469.


Custom Gift Box

If one of our gift boxes doesn't work for you or you'd like to add something to your gift box, just contact us and let us know what you'd like us to put together for you.  Once we receive your email, we'll email/call you back with final pricing and get your approval before we process the order.


Here are the individual prices for each item that is currently in stock:


Artisan Butter:

  • Cultured Butter with Sea Salt 8 oz. - $8


Soft Ripened Cheeses

  • Trillium 8 oz. - $13
  • Foxglove 8 oz. -$13
  • Tiger Lily 8 oz - $13
  • Chicory 10 oz - $15

Semi Soft Cheeses

  • Hops (Beer Cheese) 8 oz - $9
  • Dutch Tulip 8 oz - $9 (currently unavailable)

Longer Aged Cheeses

  • Nightshade - 8 oz aged 12 months 8 oz $10

Fresh Cheese

  • Fromage Frais 8 oz - $7
  • Nettle 6 oz - $7


Additional Cost:

  • Shipping box & Packing material $10-$15 (based on size number of items)
  • Shipping cost (varies based on distance) - Ground is around $12 - $17


You can also pick up from the creamery!


Print Print | Sitemap
© Creamery